Research Is Medicine
Video
Research Is Medicine
Audio
Doctors Jack Snyder and Monish Sheth join Dr. Michael Koren to explain the Academy of Physicians and Clinical Research (APCR) position on the intersection of research and medicine. They explain that the unanimous opinion of the Academy is that clinical research is indeed clinical medicine, and that clinical research is actually a subspecialty of medicine. The trio talk about the legality, ethics, and requirements of clinical research and how it cannot be separated from clinical practice. The three doctors finish by explaining that medicine is regulated at the state level, and that this has implications of clinical research.
The document referenced by Dr. Koren:
Clinical Research Involves the Practice of Medicine
Participating in clinical research gives patients immediate access to novel therapies, diagnostic tools, and management strategies long before they are commercially available on pharmacy shelves.
Research protocols demand frequent, comprehensive evaluations, meticulous safety monitoring, and rigorous tracking, which often translates to a higher frequency and intensity of clinical attention for the patient.
For patients with chronic, treatment-resistant, or palliative conditions where standard-of-care options have failed, clinical trials serve as a vital, medically sound care option.
Community- and office-based physician-investigators bring everyday clinical realities—such as geriatric comorbidities, polypharmacy, and diverse patient demographics—directly into study design.
Modern models like pragmatic or practice-based clinical trials test interventions within authentic, everyday healthcare settings rather than isolated laboratory environments, merging trial execution with routine medical workflow.
Every act of medical treatment carries a degree of uncertainty; systematic clinical research formalizes how physicians test, evaluate, and refine the safety and efficacy of interventions.
Medicine cannot remain static. Integrating clinical research into practice ensures that standards of care evolve based on high-quality empirical data rather than habit or tradition.
A physician's duty extends beyond treating the person in front of them to improving the broader body of medical knowledge that protects future patients.
Engagement in research keeps physicians deeply connected to medical literature, critical appraisal, and specialized peer networks, sharpening their day-to-day diagnostic and therapeutic decision-making.
Clinical research conducted by physicians is legally and regulatorily intertwined with the practice of medicine because investigators exercise direct clinical judgment, diagnose, treat, and assume direct legal responsibility for human lives.
Under FDA regulations (such as 21 CFR 312.60), a physician serving as a principal investigator is personally responsible for the medical care, health, and welfare of trial participants throughout the study. Administering investigational drugs, devices, or biologics constitutes a medical intervention.
The AMA Code of Medical Ethics dictates that physicians must only participate in clinical trials that directly relate to their licensed scope of practice and specific area of medical expertise. Research is not legally separated from medical licensing standards.
Obtaining informed consent mirrors the legal and ethical requirement for informed consent in routine medical treatment—requiring a physician (or delegated qualified clinician) to explain risks, benefits, and alternative medical options in the context of a patient's health status.
Physicians in research must continuously evaluate patient responses, manage complications, and report serious adverse events to sponsors and Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) => this obligation is identical to the clinical duty of care a doctor owes a patient presenting with side effects or worsening pathology.
Regulatory frameworks (including FDA and HHS rules) recognize that a physician-investigator often acts simultaneously as the patient’s treating physician => this "double agent" dynamic requires managing clinical vs. research conflicts of interest to ensure that patient-subject well-being is never compromised for trial enrollment metrics.
From a state medical board licensing perspective, clinical research involving human subjects is considered the practice of medicine because it directly impacts patient safety, involves diagnostic or therapeutic interventions, and falls under the broad statutory definition of treating or managing patients.
Clinical research frequently administers experimental drugs, biologics, or medical devices to human subjects, which constitutes active medical intervention and patient management.
State medical boards derive their authority from the Tenth Amendment to protect the public from incompetent or unsafe medical practices, meaning any hands-on clinical interaction—research or standard care—requires state oversight.
State Medical Practice Acts generally define medicine as diagnosing, treating, operating on, or prescribing for any human disease, pain, injury, deformity, or physical condition, which includes clinical trial protocols.
Physicians engaged in research retain a medical and ethical duty of care to their subjects, requiring clinical judgment to monitor adverse events, interpret diagnostic tests, and decide whether to alter or halt a patient’s participation for safety reasons.
State boards view a physician's license as a continuous prerequisite for evaluating patient eligibility, managing baseline health conditions during a trial, and handling acute medical complications that arise during research protocols.
Tex. Admin. Code § 177.1(2) defines actively engaged in the practice of medicine as follows: “The physician on a full-time basis is engaged in diagnosing, treating or offering to treat any mental or physical disease or disorder or any physical deformity or injury or performing such actions with respect to individual patients for compensation and shall include clinical medical research, the practice of clinical investigative medicine, the supervision and training of medical students or residents in a teaching facility or program approved by the Liaison Committee on Medical Education of the American Medical Association, the American Osteopathic Association or the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education, and professional managerial, administrative, or supervisory activities related to the practice of medicine or the delivery of health care services. The term “full-time basis,” for purposes of this section, shall mean at least 20 hours per week for 40 weeks duration during a given year.”
Hospitals and research institutions can be held vicariously liable under tort law for the medical negligence of their employed physicians during a clinical trial. This legal connection relies on the physician's actions being recognized as professional medical practice within the scope of their employment.
Transcripts
Transcript generated by AI:
Research Inside Clinical Workflow
Jack Snyder 0:00
So what Monish what Monish is describing is the integration of experimental work and observational clinical research into the routine of clinical workflow. And to the extent that we've got technology and standards of care now being applied not only in routine clinical workflow, but also to that integrated experimental and observational data gathering, that also I think, again, speaks to the emphasis on clinical research being the practice of medicine.
Announcer 0:37
Welcome
Welcome And Why This Matters
Announcer 0:38
to MedEvidence! Where we help you navigate the truth behind medical research with unbiased evidence-proven facts, hosted by cardiologist and top medical researcher, Dr. Michael Koren.
Dr. Michael Koren 0:49
Hello, I'm Dr. Michael Koren, the executive editor of MedEvidence! And we have a real treat for you today. Two of my colleagues from an organization called the Academy of Physicians and Clinical Research are going to join me today and discuss a very important resolution that came out of our recent national meeting. So it's my great pleasure to introduce Dr. Monet Sheth, who is the immediate past president of the Academy of Physicians and Clinical Research, and Dr. Jack Snyder, who is the new president of the Academy of Physicians in Clinical Research, which we will call APCR from here on in. Gentlemen, thank you for joining me on MedEvidence!
Monish Sheth 1:32
Thank you, Jack, for inviting. It's been a pleasure. And I'm here today to discuss the important issue we addressed at our annual meeting in Florida. So thank you.
Dr. Michael Koren 1:43
Yeah, so we had a tremendous and-
Jack Snyder 1:46
-likewise I'm delighted to be here.
Dr. Michael Koren 1:48
Thank you, Jack, for being part of this. So we had a really robust and wonderful discussion about something that I don't think should be controversial, but yet is still something that gets questioned.
The Core Question For APCR
Dr. Michael Koren 2:02
And that simple question is: is clinical research the practice of medicine? And we had a very, very interesting discussion around that. And ultimately the group unanimously stated that we will make a consensus statement to make it clear. And just for everybody's knowledge, APCR is a subspecialty body of the American Medical Association House of Medicine. So we're considered a subspecialty of medicine. And some even that is something that's not completely understood. We understand cardiology is a subspecialty, surgery is a subspecialty, pathology is a subspecialty, but people don't always recognize that clinical research is also a subspecialty in the eyes of the American Medical Association. So I'm going to read word for word the consensus statement just so everybody can hear this, including our audience, and then I'll let you guys give us your reactions to what this consensus statement means moving forward and the clarity that we hopefully will generate through this statement.
The Consensus Statement Read Aloud
Dr. Michael Koren 3:05
So very simply, the statement reads Clinical research is the practice of medicine. Specifically for physicians, clinical research is a subspecialty and a subset of the practice of medicine. While clinical research is different than standard clinical practice, the ethical principles and laws that apply to the practice of medicine equally apply to the practice of clinical research. So I'll start with you, Jack. Your reaction to that, and should that be controversial and maybe add some other clarity. You, by the way, I didn't mention, are an attorney, physician, and somebody that's worked in industry for a long period of time. So you may want to also mention some of your background, which is absolutely impressive.
Accountability Liability And Informed Consent
Jack Snyder 3:52
Well, I'm I'm gonna start by letting everyone know that we are now in an age of heightened accountability. And as a result of being in the age of accountability, we have to look very closely at what physicians are doing, including their activities in clinical research. When we talk about accountability, we're talking in the clinical research arena, we're talking about physicians directing patient care in that context. We're also talking about shared decision making in that context of research. And we're also, very importantly, talking about potential liability in that context. So whether we're talking about delivering care, that is diagnosing or managing or treating or providing individualized patient benefit, I think in this day and age that clearly counts as the or should be recognized as the practice of medicine. And yes, malpractice liability and liability for protocol breaches and for staff misconduct and for less than appropriate informed consent, as well as even research fraud, have all of those issues have been developed or they have been visited upon clinical research physicians.
Dr. Michael Koren 5:22
Yeah, that that wonderfully stated. And I I want to emphasize your background and credentials, Jack, because they are unique. So your current employment is in industry, but you have an absolute incredible curriculum vitae. So just share some of those points that are relevant for this discussion, if you don't mind.
Jack Snyder 5:43
Well, so I I have been practicing medicine and also been licensed as an attorney for more than 30 years. And in in the context, I've also served as the president, I'm now the past president of the American College of Legal Medicine. I rub shoulders with a lot of folks at the interface of law and medicine for many decades now. And in that context, I can strongly suggest to your audience that again, it's about accountability at that medical legal interface. And that is what I think strongly supports any argument that clinical research represents the practice of medicine. I hope that helps.
Hospital Trials And Real-Time Care Decisions
Dr. Michael Koren 6:34
That's tremendous. Absolutely tremendous. So Manish, you're a physician in practice, very involved in clinical trials. And why don't you give us your perspective from the standpoint of a practical practicing physician, particularly somebody that does clinical research on a day-to-day basis?
Monish Sheth 6:52
Yeah, so yes. So giving my background, so I do clinical research and I'm a hospitalist. So most of my patients and when I'm enrolling patients, they are they are in the hospital. So there is no argument on what we discuss at our annual meeting. But let's say if I have to make an argument that if a patient is enrolled in a clinical trial and all of a sudden at 2 a.m. they become hypotensive or anything else happens, they don't not become my patients. I still have to take care of them. I have to decipher where to take deviation from research, if it is part of all research. And when a physician's oversight matters the most, being in the hospital, taking any side effects or adverse effects into consideration. So for me, I mean, it's very hard to separate practice of medicine not being a part of research. That's like the essential of how my research role is.
Dr. Michael Koren 7:47
Have you had it? So-
Jack Snyder 7:48
-what Monish is describing is the integration of experimental work and observational clinical research into the routine of clinical workflow. And to the extent that we've got technology and standards of care now being applied not only in routine clinical workflow, but also to that integrated experimental and observational data gathering, that also I think, again, speaks to the emphasis on clinical research being the practice of medicine.
Dr. Michael Koren 8:29
Well said. Very, very well said. Manish, have you experienced anything in your professional career where people would push back against the notion of research being the practice of medicine?
Monish Sheth 8:44
No, I think they they all look up because the research is not a big teamwork, right? I mean, you have so many people helping and supporting research, whether it's just an administrator, a nurse, or a lab, everybody is an integral part. And I think as a frontline physician who is directly involved with the patient, they value our opinion, whether whether it's just a clinical oversight or it being a design for the research protocol itself.
GCP R3 And What Oversight Matters
Monish Sheth 9:15
And the reason I say that is I think because the at APCR we do this monthly webinar, and I did the good clinical practice R3 update two months ago. And the R3 revision states like not every part of research mandates similar kind of oversight. So we have to prioritize what is essential and what are the critical steps we want to make sure that are taken care of as a physician to protect the patient well-being. So yeah, fortunately, no, I've been blessed to work in an environment where the practice of medicine indirectly or directly is emphasized.
Dr. Michael Koren 9:58
Excellent.
State Regulation Versus FDA Oversight
Dr. Michael Koren 9:59
And Jack, I I was a huge admirer of your beautiful analysis that I have right by my side here that we'll post with this podcast that looked at a number of issues and why clinical research is in fact the practice of medicine, including the very important understanding that in the United States, the practice of medicine is actually regulated on a state-by-state basis. And sometimes that gets lost when we talk about, quote, FDA sanctioned studies or FDA studies, uh studies that are undergoing an IND process and FDA oversight. But at the end of the day, the actual practice of medicine occurs at the state level. And sometimes those elements of what we do get overlooked. I don't know if you have any comments about that.
Jack Snyder 10:45
Well, not only do I agree with everything you just said, but it's probably worth re-emphasizing that the FDA itself has said, even in legal proceedings, that it is not in the business of practicing medicine. And indeed, that is why physicians are held accountable in the practice in clinical research, because the FDA, as the regulatory body, is not in the practice of medicine. And courts have so held. In it's again, as you point out, the practice of medicine is at the state level.
Dr. Michael Koren 11:23
Thank you so much.
Jack Snyder 11:24
And every practice and every practitioner who gets involved in clinical research would do themselves a great favor by learning what it is that their particular state requires of all physicians in all types of interactions with patients or clinical trial participants.
Dr. Michael Koren 11:49
Well, gentlemen, we're we're going to certainly put Dr. Snyder's beautiful analysis as part as a document as part of this podcast. Thank you both for your really important contributions to MedEvidence! Any final words in terms of this issue, Jack, from you first?
Jack Snyder 12:05
I'd like to congratulate you, Dr. Koren, on bringing this issue to the fore in this particular forum. And I hope that we from time to time can re-emphasize the very important points that you've brought to light here. And thank you for the opportunity to participate.
Dr. Michael Koren 12:23
Oh, my pleasure. Monish, you get the last word.
AMA Ethics And Final Takeaways
Monish Sheth 12:26
Yeah, I think I would just end by saying like uh I would just reiterate like how this correlates with our AMA Code of Medical Ethics. I think there was a one statement which I read which explicitly states that physician researchers have ethical obligations to protect research participants and demonstrate the same care and concern for their well-being as for patients and their therapeutic relationship. So I think that AMA statement itself points towards what we are doing as part as a part of practice of medicine.
Dr. Michael Koren 12:58
I fully agree with that. Gentlemen, thank you both for being part of the MedEvidence family and being part of this important podcast.
Monish Sheth 13:06
Thank you. Our pleasure.
Announcer 13:08
Thanks for joining the MedEvidence Podcast. To learn more, head over to MedEvidence.com or subscribe to our podcast on your favorite podcast platform.